“`html
Farhan Akhtar Calls Naseeruddin Shah’s Public Criticism “Distasteful”: A Look Back at the Bhaag Milkha Bhaag Row
Bollywood often witnesses differing opinions, but few spark as much conversation as a public critique from a veteran actor. Recently, Farhan Akhtar opened up about the “distasteful” remarks made by Naseeruddin Shah back in 2013 regarding his critically acclaimed film, ‘Bhaag Milkha Bhaag’.
Shah had not held back, calling the biopic “a completely fake film” and questioning Farhan’s acting prowess. Now, a decade later, Farhan Akhtar has addressed the deep personal hurt caused by these comments, shedding light on the unspoken etiquette of critique within the industry.
Farhan Akhtar’s Response: “Distasteful”
During a recent interaction, Farhan Akhtar reflected on Naseeruddin Shah’s harsh words from 2013. He labeled the public nature of the criticism as “distasteful,” emphasizing the long-standing personal connection they share.
This candid response brings to the forefront the complexities of relationships and professional feedback in the high-stakes world of cinema.
A Childhood Connection and Deep Hurt
In an interview with India Today, Farhan Akhtar revealed how much Shah’s remarks affected him, especially given their history. “I have known him for so many years,” Akhtar stated, recalling their collaboration in ‘Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara’.
He added, “He knows me ever since I was a child.” Despite respecting Shah as a “great performer and a great actor,” Farhan found the method of communication deeply unsettling.
The Preference for Private Feedback
Farhan Akhtar expressed a clear preference for private, constructive criticism over public disparagement. He outlined how he believes such feedback should be delivered:
- Direct Communication: “I would have picked up a phone and told the person to come home.”
- Constructive Criticism: Share specific points of improvement, like “I found these points lacking.”
- Encouragement for Growth: Advise, “if you’re passionate for acting, then you should work on these things.”
“This is a way of communicating. But to go in the press and say this… I found that distasteful,” Farhan asserted. He clarified that while Shah is entitled to his opinion, the chosen platform for his critique was problematic.
Recalling Naseeruddin Shah’s Strong Critique
The controversy dates back to 2013 when Bhaag Milkha Bhaag, a biopic on Olympian Milkha Singh, was released. Naseeruddin Shah was notably vocal about his disapproval.
He made his views public through various statements, creating a stir in Bollywood circles.
“A Completely Fake Film”
Back in 2013, Shah did not mince words, telling IANS that he considered ‘Bhaag Milkha Bhaag’ to be “a completely fake film.” His criticism extended directly to Farhan Akhtar’s portrayal of Milkha Singh.
Shah famously remarked, “Farhan has no doubt worked very hard but building up muscles and growing your hair is not exactly working hard on your acting. At least he should have tried to look like Milkha. Milkha is mighty pleased by him and he imagines that this was his life, he imagines he looked like that. Doesn’t he have photographs of himself from the 1960s Olympics?” These strong comments certainly left a lasting impression.
‘Bhaag Milkha Bhaag’: Success Beyond the Controversy
Despite the pointed criticism from Naseeruddin Shah, ‘Bhaag Milkha Bhaag’ soared to become a significant commercial and critical success. The film garnered widespread appreciation from audiences and critics alike.
It was lauded for its inspiring storytelling, exceptional music, powerful direction, and Farhan Akhtar’s dedicated performance, solidifying its place as a memorable sports drama in Indian cinema history.
What’s Next for Farhan Akhtar?
On the work front, Farhan Akhtar is set to appear in the upcoming war film ‘120 Bahadur’. Directed by Razneesh ‘Razy’ Ghai and produced by Excel Entertainment and Trigger Happy Studios, the film promises another intense performance.
Akhtar will portray Major Shaitan Singh, alongside Raashii Khanna as his wife, Shagun Kanwar. The movie is based on the iconic Battle of Rezang La, where 120 soldiers of the Charlie Company, 13 Kumaon Regiment, valiantly defended their post against a formidable 3000-strong Chinese Army contingent.
Conclusion: The Fine Line of Feedback in Film
Farhan Akhtar’s recent comments bring an important discussion to the fore: the impact of public criticism, especially when a personal history is involved. While freedom of opinion is paramount, the manner and platform of delivery can significantly alter its reception.
The ‘Bhaag Milkha Bhaag’ episode serves as a reminder that even acclaimed films and performances can spark debate, but respectful dialogue, even when critical, often yields better outcomes for all involved.
“`